Ever since Gotham began, I’ve wanted to talk about it so much. But there are few people close to me watching the show, and some are still catching up. Now that I have this blog, I will rant and rave to my heart’s content.
There are a lot of bases I’d like to cover with Gotham. For today, I will focus on two major villains: Fish Mooney (played by Jada Pinkett Smith) and Oswald Cobblepot, a.k.a. the Penguin (played by Robin Lord Taylor).
Fish Mooney is an original character created specifically for the show. A mobstress working for Don Carmine Falcone, she’s secretly planning on bringing “the old man” down and taking his place.
Let me begin by saying that I hate Smith’s acting in Gotham. It is horrible. The way she moves, the way she speaks-it’s so badly stereotypical and makes Mooney look like a caricature. Because of that, I can’t take her or her character seriously. I groan every time she does one of her characteristic trait moves.
The acting goes hand in hand with the character, and unfortunately, Mooney is not a great character. We know practically nothing about her. Sure, there was that small little bit about her growing up with her mom (even though parts of it were lies), but that’s not enough. There is nothing about Mooney that I can relate to or sympathize with. She is just another stock villain used for the sake of being evil. She doesn’t even intimidate me at all.
Now with that out of the way, let’s talk about the real villain between the two-Oswald Cobblepot.
Where to begin?
Oswald Cobblepot (the future Penguin) starts off as a low-level grunt working for Mooney. But after a series of events, including the faking of his death (spoilers!), he begins his conquest for power and his revenge against Mooney.
Well, first off, it has to be said that Robin Lord Taylor’s acting is brilliant. Just brilliant. And personally speaking, I think he’s the best Penguin ever! He has totally changed who the Penguin is for me. Like with Deadpool, I had a fixed mental image before Gotham (Penguin=squat, cowardly bully of a mobster with serious case of Napoleon Complex). But Taylor completely blew that image to pieces with his stunning portrayal. Bravo!
Like with Mooney, the acting and character go hand in hand with Taylor and Cobblepot. But in contrast to Mooney, Penguin is one of the most well developed villains in the show, hands down. Since the beginning of Gotham , we’ve seen how much he’s grown, from lowly grunt to total game-changer. With every episode, we’ve come to realize just how much of a mastermind Cobblepot really is. And, as well as getting glimpses of the inner neurotic psychopath inside, we’ve also gotten to see his humanity, particularly in the adorable yet creepy scenes with his mother.
Partially because of my aforementioned mental image, I didn’t know what to expect of Cobblepot after the pilot, other than not much. But after E4 (“Arkham”), it was just one clever surprise tactic after another in my face. E7 (“Penguin’s Umbrella”, which I’ll discuss in a later post) was the move that totally blew me away. Now I just can’t imagine what he’ll do next. All I know is this: there is no such thing as a small move for Cobblepot. The things he does, he does for a reason. It might not always make sense in the moment, but sooner or later it will.
One does not simply underestimate the Penguin.
Now, with the characters in relation to each other, I’d just like to finish with a look into the future.
Mooney is clearly not on the same level as Penguin. She says that Falcone is “weak and feeble”, but I don’t think that’s true. From everything we saw and learned in E7, I think he may be at his sharpest right now. From the look of things, it’s Mooney who’s getting weak and feeble. She can’t see the intricacy of the games that Penguin’s playing with her. And if she doesn’t, then she’s so going down. Maybe even very soon.
Penguins, after all, do eat fish.
With Cobblepot, it’s fairly easy. The only people he really has to worry about are Falcone and Maroni. But when it comes to Mooney, she’s nothing. Cobblepot plays her so easily, and he will keep playing her until (if it happens) he gets his revenge on her.
No matter what happens, Mooney’s going down. Hopefully it’s sometime in Season One. I can’t stand the thought of having to see her for another season.
What do you think? Do you like Smith’s acting and her character? What do you think of Taylor’s portrayal of Penguin? Let me know in the comments!
‘Til next time, laters!